“discovering” the classics: apple pie.
I had never really had apple pie before.
And by that, I mean I had never had REAL apple pie before. Let’s start at the beginning. I’m the son of immigrants who met in the states, married in the states, and had children in the states. And my folks did the best they could to be American. While we were definitely a true Hispanic family, we celebrated American holidays, spoke English, and ate American foods; one of which my father had developed a particular affinity for: apple pie.
Now, I know I said that I had never really had apple pie. But, before you rush to point out my inconsistencies, I should elaborate on the distinction I make between the apple pie my father loves and real apple pie. Real apple pie is filled with succulently juicy, tart and spicy apples, encased in a buttery, crisp, flaky crust. It’s a work of poetic alchemy in the way that these things just come together and are transformed by each other. Real apple pie doesn’t need ice cream or even whipped cream; on the contrary it can make a devout Taoist out of the most staunch Hedonist.
My father… likes supermarket apple pie. And if this this seemed like an overly blunt transition, you’re right. But it was all I ever knew for the better part of my life. And it’s a great example of how challenging it is for immigrants to lean unspoken cultural idiosyncrasies. Because I’m guessing somewhere in some conversation, my father heard that apple tastes great with whipping cream, but no one told my father he should actually whip the cream first. So at some point, my father must’ve rushed to the supermarket, bought an apple pie, a carton of whipping cream, and not knowing any better, poured the cream over his generous slice of pie. So effectively, we would eat cold apple pie stew… a sad sliver of cardboard crust encasing (likely) canned apples that maybe were part of living organism 10 years ago, drenched in a pool of heavy cream. But we felt American, and that was important to us. Just as important as feeling Latino.
I had never really had apple pie before.
And the fun and scary thing about baking is that I’ve really had never had anything before. I say it’s “fun” because all of a sudden, things that I never really liked before are becoming my favorite things ever. “Scary” because I’m never really sure if it’s… right. Delicious, attractive, yes yes yes. But is it right?
Being the son of immigrants brings about a cultural insecurity in many aspects of life… Jokes that everyone else gets except for me; references to movies that came out before I even knew how to speak English. Did I make it into this school because I’m smart or because they need more diversity? So you’re not supposed to pour un-whipped cream on top of your apple pie?
But there’s something magical about discovering a piece of traditional archaism for the first time and to revel it as something of novelty. There’s something magical about your parents giving you their ceiling so that it could be your floor. And there’s something magical about knowing that there’s better apple pies out there, but still going to your folks’ house, cutting a slice of supermarket pie, and pouring un-whipped heavy cream over it; for old times’ sake.
“My” apple pie
Normally you can come to expect a recipe associated with my blog posts, but in this case, I feel inclined to do something a bit different. Although I’ve been making this apple pie for 4 years now, and it’s become a trusty weapon in my recipe arsenal (not “my” apple pie as much as it is my “go-to” apple pie); I haven’t dared to tweak this recipe or alter it. And I think that speaks to two things: it’s unique enough that even bold deviations still point back to the original author, and it’s good enough as is.
So, you want to make this beautiful pie, right? This recipe is from my all time baking heroine, Rose Levy Beranbaum as written in “The Baking Bible.” It features a unique cream cheese/butter pastry crust that is crisp, flaky and tender, as well as a delightful addition of apple cider to the filling. The pie pictured in this blog is faithful to the recipe, adding only the light brushing of an egg wash glaze prior to baking.
It is my sincerest hope that you enjoy this pie and this author as much as I do. And I hope it becomes just as much “yours” as it is “mine.”
“Heirloom” by Sleeping At Last
you try your hardest to leave the past alone.
this crooked posture is all you’ve ever known.
it is the consequence of living in between
the weight of family and the pull of gravity.
you are so much more than your father’s son.
you are so much more than what i’ve become.
long before you were born
there was light hidden deep
in these young, unfamiliar eyes.
a million choices, though little on their own,
become the heirloom of the heaviness you’ve known.
you are so much more than your father’s son.
you are so much more than what i’ve become,
what i’ve become,
what i’ve become.
you pressed rewind for the thousandth time
when the tapes wore through.
so you memorized those unscripted lines,
desperate for some kind of clue:
when the scale tipped,
when you inherited a fight that you were born to lose.
it’s not your fault, no,
it’s not your fault,
i put this heavy heart in you.
i put this heavy heart in you.
you remind me of who i could have been,
had i been stronger and braver way back then.
a million choices, though little on their own,
became the heirloom of the heaviness we’ve known.
you are so much more than your father’s son.
you are so much more than the wars you’ve won.
you are so much more than your father’s son.
you are so much more than what i’ve become.